“You deny who you are by hoping to make yourself different.”
That was a comment from another of these “gay pigeonholers”, posted over at My Hetero Gay Life*.
What an absolutely bizarre notion! Of course I hope to make myself different; I do not consider who I am now to be so close to perfect as to lack room for improvement. Or looking back – am I the same person that I am now (at 31) as I was at 15? No – thank God! Do I hope to be the same way in another 31 years? Absolutely not.
But I doubt that that’s exactly what the commenter (“ewe”) meant. (S/he’s welcome to explain here if s/he really likes.) I suspect that the meaning rather was “by hoping to be not-gay, you deny that you are gay”. Except that that makes no sense either.
Perhaps, “you deny that what you are is good, if you hope to be otherwise”. (The statements “what you are is good” and “what you are is perfect” are not of course identical.) Well, that part may be true enough; I suppose that, if Jay (of M.H.G.L.) confidently agreed with the idea that he should leave his wife and kids and “straight life” behind, he wouldn’t be blogging about his struggle to resist that.
On the other hand, why on earth should anyone be content with the way he is now? (As far as “degree of perfection” goes, anyway, and distinct from being “content in every circumstance”.) Would you tell a fat man “you deny yourself, if you ever hope to make yourself thin”? or an alcoholic, “you deny yourself, if you ever hope to keep yourself sober”? or a single man (of any orientation) “you deny yourself, if you ever hope to find a partner”?
(“But those are all BAD things that you compare it to! That’s homophobic!” Fine – but the whole point of the comparison is to other circumstances in which someone wants to change. Does a fit man wish to be fat? Does a happy sober man want to wash his life down the drain with a bottle of Scotch? Not everyone who has same-sex desires is happy with them, and people (like ewe) who suggest otherwise can be astoundingly offensive about that fact. “It’s good enough for me! you should like it too!” Yes, and heterosexual desires are “good enough” for most people…)
“You deny who you are”… No, he’s just accepting that there are bonds and vows more important than lust, and that life can be far more complicated than some would try to pretend. Or, to put it another way – he’s being more than gay, choosing to be his own man rather than stamping himself into a mold.
Another gem from ewe: “it is gay people that tolerate straight people, not the other way around which is what we are led to believe is needed.” Right, ’cause you sure don’t tolerate gay people who aren’t gay in the way you think they should be.
*(Great blog, that, by the way… I can very easily see myself in a similar situation, so it resonates quite strongly with me. And I absolutely admire his honesty about the conflicts he feels, and his determination to “man up”, denying his own desires for the sake of his wife and family. That takes far more balls than jumping out of the closet into a world of show tunes and gay pride parades ever would.)